The Good - I wear these shoes to the office weekly. They are so comfortable and look great with all pieces of my wardrobe. I will probably buy other colors. I was unsure of sizing so I sent a question to customer service along with my foot measurements and they were able to assist. Got my sizing right on the first purchase.
The Bad - The bottom of the heels scuff VERY easily. For the price, it's quite disappointing. I have bought other pairs recommended by Anya (Anya's loafers and FeelBarefoot) and this is my first and so far only disappointment. I have worn all the shoes in the photo about equally, but for some reason the leather on these shoes is not of the same quality as other brands, or maybe it's a design flaw. The other shoes seem to have a slightly thicker sole which may prevent the scuffing. Either way, for the price this should not be an issue.